Digging for gold in prison art class: Finding goodness, autonomy, and great art

Posted by Phyllis Kornfeld
Tuesday, August 26, 2008

Art Class, By Charles Mosby

I’m so pleased to include Phyllis’s piece on her work with incarcerated individuals, teaching them about positivity, responsibility, and creative self-expression through the vehicle of art. Through her belief in and expectations for her students, she creates a space of excellence and invites them into it. I would imagine for many of her students, this is a brand new experience that opens their eyes and hearts to what is possible in their lives. The beautiful future we want to create isn’t just for people who already have it all together. The work Phyllis does gives us a model for how we can go about widening the circle of acceptance and hope for everyone. -editor

Following my education, I began teaching art in various traditional venues. I was never quite satisfied, or enthusiastic, about any of them until I took a job teaching painting and drawing in Oklahoma State prisons to men and women incarcerated in medium and maximum-security facilities. That clicked. That was where my heart found its home, and that is the population I’ve been working with ever since, for the last twenty-five years.

“Art Teacher” didn’t seem the right job description after a few weeks of working behind bars. Some of the men and women had already created strikingly fresh work without benefit of an art program or decent materials. 

Teaching the conventional principals, techniques, and subject matter—in other words, what was taught to me—not only seemed irrelevant, but I knew that such an approach was likely to put a lid on the intense yearning to create that was obvious, and poignant, in most of the people who came to my classes.

I thought perhaps “artist facilitator” was a more appropriate job description— provide space and materials, protection for the work, opportunities for exhibition, and minimal, gradual guidance away from cliché and into the new.

These days, I can’t help thinking of myself as an excavator. Facilitator doesn’t seem to match the urgency I feel to unleash the force for goodness that is the creative impulse. I am vigorously engaged in something analogous to digging for gold.

The Neighborhood, by Arthur Keigney

With every person I meet, behind bars for six months or twenty-five years or life, I begin with the certainty that they have within them the wherewithal to make truth, beauty, and goodness visible and tangible. The gold is there, almost always.

It might already be actualized, shining, as with a few of the exceptionally talented self-motivated people, or just under the surface, ready to burst forth. Or, it might require excavation.

The obstacles, layers of mud and dust to be swept aside, shoveled out, or blasted to smithereens, are the fixed images of self, mostly negative, that the great majority thoroughly believe themselves to be.

It may be true that they have done bad things, and most have actually been victimized themselves, but it is crucial that they begin to experience the potential for goodness and the capacity for autonomy that is inherent in being human.

In my art class there are no pictures of hearts and roses, praying hands, spider webs, tearful eyes, tattoo flash, or any of the other stereotypical jailhouse imagery. And there are no generic scenes of lighthouses, covered bridges, city skylines, and all the other shopworn subjects that are stereotypes on the outside.

Time’s Up, By Larry Mocks

I am not saying that making this kind of popular art is not a good thing. It is very good, no matter what the quality, because the making of it is a peaceful positive endeavor, releasing stress and engendering cooperation among the inmate population.

People teach each other how to do it. They keep up their family ties by sending work home. They earn and give respect to each other for their artistic accomplishments, but art class is a different story.

Art class is designed to effect real transformation that is only achieved when a person can see and touch a truly inventive, excellent, inspired work of art that they themselves have created from a source that is deep and mysterious.

There are two uncompromising ground rules for all. They are simple, sure-fire shortcuts to leaving the ego behind – to silence the familiar voice that repeats, “No I can’t.”

The first is no speaking personally. I define this as talking about “What I like and what I don’t like, where I’ve been and where I’m going, what I can do and what I can’t do, and especially, how I feel.”

Untitled, By Brenda Ramos

Do not express these. You can of course think whatever you are thinking – feel whatever you are feeling – but do not speak it aloud. This works magnificently. Something new and deep is given access to express itself. Something good, fresh, energetic, and positive.

The other is no negativity. I explain: “This does not apply to your artwork—but to your words and sounds and body language. You may not express anything negative like – I can’t draw hands, this is a mess, I am upset, depressed, not in the mood. I have a problem, a stomachache, the weather stinks.”

Check out the difference between, “I can’t draw horses,” and “I would like to learn to draw horses.” The former slams a door shut. The latter opens to possibility.

When someone in the group does inadvertently express negativity, the others jump on it before I do. They are good-natured about it, but we all know that if it continues, the offender will have to leave.

In this art class it doesn’t matter how you feel. It only matters what you do. At the very least, adherence to these rules reduces the volume of the ego’s fears and negativity.

At best, the authentic self, which is goodness, takes over completely, and there is an explosion of creativity that surprises everyone. It is my observation that the best art (and the best self) rises to the surface when its creation is not fundamentally motivated by personal gain.

I encourage people to think of their artwork as a gift to the world. At this, they sit up straight and proceed with focus and dignity.

The idea is to change the culture - to shift our core values from getting to giving – in prison and elsewhere. The gold, unearthed, is for everyone.

Filed under • Art
(2) Comments | (0) Trackbacks | Permalink
Phyllis KornfeldSee more articles by Phyllis Kornfeld.
Next entry: Democracy Challenge #3: Making progress by sticking with it Previous entry: Good news newsreel for August
Victoria Gagliano  on  08/27  at  10:29 AM

Such a beautifully written piece, Interesting how your idea of yourself has changed from teacher, to facilitator, to excavator.  It seems that your perception of what you do has also changed just as the individuals perceptions of themselves changes as they create art.

Your strategies of silencing the “I can’t” voice reminded me of this quote:
If you hear a voice within you say “you cannot paint,” then by all means paint, and that voice will be silenced. ~~ Van Gogh

Sarah Moon  on  08/27  at  04:35 PM

Dear Phyllis,
Thank you for sharing this piece. I loved the way you described yourself as an excavator seeking to unleash a force for goodness. It made me think very much of my work with ESL students this summer who face many “I can’ts” in their struggle to prepare for English skills exams. A big part of that job too is silencing the negativity to let deeper, truer thoughts and feelings emerge. As I continued to read, I thought less of my students and more of myself as a writer and how to push past my own feelings of doubt to the act of actually doing. Your writing gave me a new way to think about my own creative work. Thank you!

Page 1 of 1 pages

Post a comment

Name:

Email:

Location:

URL:

Remember my personal information

Notify me of follow-up comments?

Submit the word you see below: